Business Owners Beware of Phishing — The Red Flags That Made Us Pause
An impressive opportunity. A recognisable company name. A professional-looking message. Then repeated pressure to use a recommended specialist before moving forward.
That was the situation I encountered recently.
As a business owner, I regularly receive introductions, proposals and enquiries. Most deserve a fair hearing. But when an approach starts raising more questions than it answers, you need to slow down and check the facts.
I’m sharing this experience because landlords, property professionals and other business owners could encounter something similar.
We have not established that this approach was fraudulent. We identified warning signs and asked for independent verification before proceeding. That distinction matters.
How the approach developed
I was approached about a senior position said to be with a well-known property business. The opportunity appeared relevant to my experience, so I was willing to explore it.
After I prepared career documents, the conversation increasingly focused on their supposed shortcomings. I was repeatedly encouraged to work with an “Executive Career Support Specialist” who, I was told, understood the hiring manager’s particular expectations.
Professional feedback is perfectly reasonable. What concerned me was the emphasis on that referral while basic details about the vacancy and the person conducting the proposed interview remained unclear.
Before spending more time on the process, I wanted straightforward answers.
The red flags
1. Basic details required repeated clarification
I asked for the hiring manager’s full name, job title and office base.
When a name was provided, I needed clarification about its order. The location also mattered: I already run a business, and a position too far away might be impractical regardless of its seniority.
An unclear name is not proof of dishonesty. But the identity of the interviewer and the location of the role should be established before an applicant is pushed into further preparation.
2. The conversation kept returning to the specialist
The recommendation appeared repeatedly, with the suggestion that my documents needed specialist attention before the opportunity could progress.
An optional service is one thing. An apparently necessary referral deserves closer scrutiny.
No payment demand is established in the correspondence discussed here. Nevertheless, official recruitment-fraud guidance warns that fraudulent approaches can involve upfront charges or referrals to other agencies for paid arrangements. Any such request should trigger independent checks. Report Fraud
3. Specific requirements were not supplied
I was told the hiring manager had particular expectations for the documents.
My response was simple: ask the hiring team to provide those requirements in writing so I could address them myself.
A clear explanation of what needs changing is useful feedback. Repeatedly saying a document needs specialist restructuring, without supplying the actual requirements, leaves the applicant unable to assess the request properly.
4. Informal checks did not resolve the uncertainty
I spoke with a former colleague who had worked for the business and maintained connections with it. He did not recognise the name provided.
That alone proves nothing. Large organisations employ many people, and former employees cannot know everyone.
It did, however, reinforce the need to verify the approach through the organisation itself.
How we handled it
I put further application work on hold and requested confirmation of:
- The vacancy and office location.
- The interviewer’s full name and job title.
- The exact time of the proposed call.
- Any specific document requirements, in writing.
- The opportunity directly through the company’s recruitment team.
The important step was moving from assurances supplied by the intermediary to independent confirmation.
The National Cyber Security Centre advises contacting an organisation through details obtained from its official website when a message causes doubt, rather than relying on the contact details supplied in that message. National Cyber Security Centre
Why this matters in property
Our industry involves frequent conversations about money, identity documents, contractors, invoices and access to buildings.
That makes verification part of everyday service.
A convincing email could concern a recruitment opportunity, a replacement invoice, changed payment instructions or an urgent request for documents. The practical question is the same: have we independently checked who is asking and what authority they have?
For a property business, sensible working habits include checking unexpected payment changes through an established contact number, keeping approval records and giving staff room to question unusual requests.
An email’s professional appearance should never replace those checks.
What other businesses can learn
You do not need to prove something is fraudulent before deciding to pause.
Ask precise questions. Request written details. Verify the organisation independently. Keep the correspondence so you can explain what happened if further action becomes necessary.
Suspicious emails can be forwarded to report@phishing.gov.uk. If money has been lost or an account compromised, GOV.UK directs people in England and Wales to Report Fraud. GOV.UK
For me, the lesson is straightforward: an attractive opportunity still needs checking.
At MyEstate, following things through means asking the awkward questions as well as handling the routine work. Our clients trust us with their properties, records and money. That trust deserves careful decisions.
Richard Gedall MNAEA | AARLA
Director | MyEstate Luton Limited
Comments